Are Some People Consistently Too Confident?
Are Some People Consistently Too Confident?
Fuqua professors studied how overconfidence is linked to certain personality profiles, with implications for business decisions and outcomes
Sound judgment is critical in business, as in life. Making good decisions under uncertainty is a coveted skill, albeit a hard one to cultivate. But are certain personalities more confident than accurate? And are certain individuals more prone to overconfidence?
“People are overconfident when they think that their performance or abilities exceed the truth,” said Rick Larrick, the Hanes Corporation Foundation Professor at Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business.
Whether such miscalibrations between confidence and accuracy are one-time errors or a persistent individual tendency is one of the questions examined in a new paper published in the journal Cognition, co-authored by Larrick, Fuqua’s Jack Soll and M. Asher Lawson of INSEAD (a Fuqua PhD graduate).
Across four studies, the researchers established that overconfidence — and its opposite, underconfidence — is indeed a stable trait in certain individuals, consistent across tasks and over time.
They also tested two possible explanations of overconfidence. For one, people simply don’t know what they don’t know and are therefore less accurate than they think. The second explanation is more motivational: some people feel the need to inflate their confidence and present themselves as better than they actually are — as with narcissistic personalities.
“Most people have a motivation to feel smart. For some people, the need to feel especially capable or superior predicts consistently high overconfidence,” Larrick said.
An individual trait?
Before now, researchers struggled to pin down overconfidence as a stable trait in individuals, Larrick said. There was no definitive way to predict whether a given individual would score consistently overconfident across tasks, as opposed to showing high confidence and inaccuracy in certain circumstances while being better calibrated in different ones.
Larrick and his co-authors thought the mixed results were a consequence of relying on too little evidence. “Researchers who study personality have learned one fundamental point: one question alone is too noisy an indicator. The very best personality scales ask many, many items to become reliable,” Larrick said.
To address the issue, the researchers measured overconfidence in multiple ways and across multiple tasks. Importantly, they repeated these experiments over time. In one study, they tested participants in 2019 and then invited them back in May 2022. In other studies, they invited participants back after one week and again three months later.
A predictable pattern of overconfidence
By averaging the results of these experiments with almost three thousand participants, the researchers found that certain individuals tend to show overconfidence (or underconfidence) consistently across tasks — although the degree of overconfidence can change depending on the specific tasks.
“We find strong evidence that overconfidence is a stable trait, not just something that emerges randomly in people, depending on the task at hand,” Larrick said. “If someone is overconfident on stock prices, they are also more likely to think they are better than average at other financial decisions.”
How thinking styles affect overconfidence
The researchers went on to explore the drivers of this stable trait.
They hypothesized two possible explanations. First, overconfidence is a “cognitive error” — we don’t know what we don’t know, so we make predictions that allow too little room for uncertainty. Second, some people express too much confidence to bolster their self-image.
When we are overconfident because of cognitive errors, “we make a prediction, we recruit a few reasons consistent with our guess, and at the end we feel like we have painted a complete picture, but we don’t see what’s missing,” Larrick said.
For example, someone could be asked to predict year-end price ranges for a bunch of stocks, with 80% confidence that the actual prices will fall within those ranges ($90–$105 for stock X, $35–$50 for stock Y). If at the end of the experiment, the actual prices fall within the person’s predicted ranges less than 80% of the time, that indicates overconfidence.
Countless studies have shown that people provide 80% ranges that capture the truth only about 40% of the time, Larrick said.
In the case of under confidence, people are instead more accurate than they think.
“This is especially true on tasks that feel hard and when questions are not ranges, but confidence about abilities,” he said. “For example, many people think that they’re worse than average at negotiating.”
To explore the cognitive explanation, the researchers tested whether certain “thinking styles” were associated with lower overconfidence. As predicted, they found that open-minded people and people who think more thoroughly when uncertain (“cognitive reflection”) were significantly less overconfident. Specifically, for any constant level of confidence, their answers were closer to the truth.
“These reflective personalities are more accurate, which, regardless of their level of confidence, makes them less overconfident,” Larrick said.
Self-view and overconfidence
In addition to cognitive errors, the researchers tested whether psychological traits such as narcissism, dominance, psychopathy and a tendency to manipulate others — called “Machiavellianism” — are linked to overconfidence.
“People with these traits use higher confidence to feel good about themselves,” Larrick said.
Using standard measures of such personality profiles, they found that participants who scored higher in these traits consistently tended to be more overconfident.
“There are about 10% of people who are high on narcissism and are consistently overconfident,” Larrick said. “Narcissistic people rate themselves as above average across all levels of performance, including poor performance. If you remove the narcissists from the sample, then the remaining poor performers are actually pretty calibrated — they know they are poor performers.”
Overconfidence in business
“We’re all familiar with the fact that, for many tasks, we think we’re better than others. For example, most people rate themselves as better-than-average drivers,” Larrick said.
When it comes to business settings, a substantial body of research has examined how overconfidence affects managerial decisions. In finance, studies have linked overconfident CEOs to specific investment decisions and acquisitions. Other research has shown that CEOs with military backgrounds are more aggressive in financing investments with higher leverage.
Fuqua’s John Graham and Campbell Harvey found that CEOs are consistently inaccurate in predicting S&P 500 returns as well as their own firms’ prospects and are more prone to pursue aggressive corporate policies.
The current paper demonstrates that overconfidence is a consistent trait in certain individuals across situations and a potential indicator of future behavior.
“It’s extremely important to know if leaders really know what they claim, and whether the fact that they seem too sure of themselves in the monthly sales meeting also predicts something about their budget estimates or hiring decisions at a later point,” Larrick said.
These findings could help organizations evaluate managers’ forecasts, assign responsibilities and predict high-risk leadership profiles.
Since a lot of current leadership research focuses on narcissistic leaders, it’s also important to assess the benefits and costs of such personalities, Larrick said.
“Confident leaders can inspire people to take action under uncertainty,” he said. “But overconfidence is dangerous if it makes you complacent, so that you expend little effort to achieve the desired outcome. It is also dangerous when you are planning for uncontrollable events — like future interest rates — and your forecasted range is too narrow. If actual rates are higher than predicted, your future borrowing may be more costly than you are planning.”
He added that whereas some people are consistently overconfident across situations, other people tend to be underconfident.
“This is also something leaders need to attend to. Who are the diamonds in the rough who have something important to contribute but often go unheard?” Larrick said.
“One general principle for better business decisions is to avoid relying too much on one person — often the loudest or most confident person — and to draw on the judgments of multiple informed people. Research shows that when people think independently before a team discussion, their individual perspectives cover a wider range of possibilities, and their final team answer yields a better range of estimates that more reliably captures the truth,” he said.
This story may not be republished without permission from Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business. Please contact media-relations@fuqua.duke.edu for additional information.